Frog Music by Emma Donoghue

Title: Frog Music

Author: Emma Donoghue

Genre: Historical Fiction, Crime

Source: Purchased

Rating: Liked it (3 out of 5)

image

In the middle of a San Francisco heat wave, Blanche Beunon is rushing home when she is knocked over by a bicyclist, Jenny Bonnet.  Bruised but otherwise o.k., Jenny takes Blanche for dinner to apologise before admitting she has nowhere to live and ending up sleeping on Blanche’s couch. Jenny is like no one Blanche has ever met.  She dresses in men’s clothes for a start and carries a gun, the complete opposite of Blanche whose entire life revolves around how she looks.

Blanche is a Dove, a burlesque dancer and a prostitute (though no one would use such a vulgar word).  She moved to San Francisco with her lover, Arthur and friend Ernest from France. Both men live off Blanche’s wages, gambling most of it away at the Faro table.  With Arthur since she was 15, Blanche doesn’t see anything wrong with this.  That is until Jenny starts asking her questions, questions she hasn’t ever asked herself.  Including why Blanche sent her and Arthur’s son to a baby farm.

It’s this question that sets the events of the book in motion because Blanche decides to bring her son home.  And stop working. Neither sits well with Arthur or Ernest, who feel their hold slipping away and try to take back control.  Unsure where to turn, Blanche looks to Jenny and the pair leave the city, only for Jenny to end up dead and Blanche searching for the killer.

Based on a true story, Frog Music opens with Jenny’s murder and it’s a great opener, one that really drew me in. The next 100 or so pages then left me wondering if this was all I was going to get. I found them incredibly slow as the story went back and forth over the previous month and how Blanche and Jenny ended up on the run before moving into the present and Blanche trying to solve the murder and get her son back. At this point, it picked up the pace, rushing at times towards the big reveal (or not as this was an unsolved murder) and I started to enjoy myself.

I did also have to wonder about the characters. I am not sure one had a redeeming characteristic…maybe Blanche with her late-found maternal instinct. Normally, that would put me off. I find it hard to like a book when I don’t like the characters. In this case, though, I felt ambiguous towards them vs. outright dislike. Jenny and Blanche are survivors and, and such, I found myself forgiving them, especially given how lawless San Fransisco was at this time (Emma Donohugue does a great job painting a picture of the city as seedy, dirty, sweaty and dangerous).

This meant that, in the end, I am sorry to say I didn’t care too much who-did-it or whether they were brought to justice or about the book overall.  It was well written and I liked it but didn’t love it.  Not for me.

7 comments
  1. I wasn’t sure about this one so I haven’t read it and now reading your review I think I made the right decision. Great and balanced review.

    1. Thank you. Don’t think I’m alone in not being blown away.

  2. Hmm… may give this one a pass. Thanks for your review.

    1. I would. Not one I can recommend. Shame because I normally like her books.

  3. I bought this today and have been wondering is there a typo on the front cover? It says: “A highly charged, elegant murder mystery…thillingly alive.” I’m not saying my vocab is massive, but I assume they meant thrillingly? Oopsie if so but I guess mistakes happen I just saw it and thought I was going mad!

    1. I hadn’t noticed! Too funny. I might start using it just to throw people. 😄

  4. […] so successful for me were Frog Music by Emma Donoghue and Not My Father’s Son by Alan Cumming, neither of which I really got away […]

Let me know what you're thinking...